The Western L&P committee met Wednesday, July 23, 2008 in Omaha, Nebraska. This well attended meeting was hosted by the Union Pacific Railroad. Both western rail carriers provided updates on year-to-date coal operations. This included the impact of recent flooding on coal movements and the actions taken by each railroad to keep traffic flowing. A progress report on the Engineering Study was given followed by a report on Eastern L&P activities. Finally, the group participated in an audience response exercise which provided an opportunity to compare this meeting's responses to many of the same questions asked in February 2008. The committee is always open to suggestions on agenda items as well as other aspects of these semi-annual meetings. The NCTA would like to thank the Union Pacific for both hosting this event and for their active participation in looking for ways to improve the value and effectiveness of these working group sessions.
Details of the meeting are available here:
Agenda for July 23, 2008UP Update - Andy Schroder
BNSF Update - Will Cunningham
Rail Car Covers for Bottom Discharge Cars - Ken Baranowski - Structural Composites
Audience Response Q&A
The Western L&P committee met Wednesday, February 20, 2008 in Dallas, Texas. Our thanks go to TrinityRail for hosting this event. The meeting began with a look at coal equities and the underlying factors driving prices and performance. Both Western rail carriers provided updates on operations, capital projects and maintenance plans. A progress report on the Engineering Study was given, followed by a report on Eastern L&P activities. Finally, the group participated in an audience response exercise in which they weighed in on a variety of factual and opinion based questions. Following lunch, TrinityRail provided the opportunity for attendees to see their RDL coal car. Approximately 80 people participated in the meeting.
Details of the meeting are available here:
Agenda for February 20, 2008Coal Markets - Pearce Hammond - Simmons & Company
BNSF Update - Steve Behn
UP Update - Andy Schroder
Engineering Study Progress Report - Mark Viz - Exponent
Audience Response Q&A
The Western L&P committee met Tuesday, July 31, 2007 at the Holiday Inn Denver International Airport. About 60 members and guests were on hand for the meeting and lunch hosted by NCTA.
Minutes of the meeting and presentations are available here:
Agenda for July 31, 2007L&P Minutes for July 31, 2007
BNSF Railroad Performance Update - Will Cunningham (BNSF)
UP Railroad Performance Update - Andy Schroder (UP)
Rio Tinto Presentation - Jim Orchard (Rio Tinto Energy America)
What if PRB Transportation Costs Were Raised 20%? - Lloyd Kelly (Greenmont Energy Consulting, LLC)
UP Capacity and Maintenance Projects - (UP)
Eastern L&P Report - Larry Rose (Detroit Edison)
The Joint Line - Southern Powder River Basin Coal Forecasting Process ("Process") is now available for use by the NCTA membership beginning with the Joint Line monthly coal forecast for April, 2007. The NCTA would like to thank Dan Gray and the entire NCTA L&P Committee Coal Forecasting Sub-team for their efforts.
JOINT LINE - SOUTHERN POWDER RIVER BASIN COAL FORECASTING PROCESS, Effective April 1, 2007
The Western Logistics and Planning Committee met on Tuesday, February 13, 2007 in the offices of the BNSF Railway in Ft.Worth, Texas. The NCTA and the over 90 meeting participants would like to express their appreciation to the BNSF Railway for hosting this event.
Minutes of the meeting, prepared by Bob Sarvela of Midwest Energy Resources, as well as some of the presentations made to the committee are available below. Additional presentations will be posted as they are made available to the webmaster.
L&P Minutes for February 13, 2007
Railroad Performance Update; 2006 Recap - Will Cunningham (BNSF)
Railroad Performance Update; 2007 Outlook - Steve Behn (BNSF)
SPRB Forecasting Sub-team Presentation - Dan Gray (Entergy)
Update on Ballast Fouling Mitigation Initiative - Tom Canter (NCTA)
Overview of Physical Plant, Upgrades, and Interfaces - Bob Sarvela (Midwest Energy)
The Western Logistics and Planning Committee met on Tuesday, June 20, 2006 at the Brown Palace Hotel in Denver, Colorado. Rio Tinto America was the luncheon host. Along with its thanks, the NCTA wishes Rio Tinto America the best of luck in their new offices in Denver.
Minutes of the meeting, prepared by Bob Sarvela of Midwest Energy Resources, and presentations given at the meeting are available here:
L&P Minutes for June 20, 2006Norbridge - The New Normal
Union Pacific Presentation
BNSF Presentation - Delivered Tons
BNSF Presentation - Joint Line Maintenance and Capital Update
Eastern L&P Report
Ballast Fouling Mitigation Report
The Western Logistics and Planning Committee met on Wednesday, February 22nd, 2006 at the Hampton Inn-Downtown in St. Louis Missouri. The NCTA would like to express it's appreciation to Ameren Energy, Peabody COALSALES, and Arch Coal for hosting this event. There were over 100 NCTA members and guests in attendance.
For a detailed review of the meeting, you can read the L&P Minutes for February 22, 2006 prepared by Bob Sarvela of Midwest Energy Resources.
Presentations made to the committee are available here or under NCTA News in the Members Section:
CANAC - Towards Sustainable Operation of 500 MNTUnion Pacific Presentation
BNSF Presentation
SPRB Forecasting Sub-team Presentation
Pace Global - First Quarter 2006 Gas Market Outlook
The Western Logistics and Planning Committee met in the offices of the Union Pacific Railroad in Omaha, Nebraska on July 20th. There were over 95 NCTA members and guests in attendance. The agenda included the PRB Joint Line Maintenance Plan, Rail Bed Coal Dust Study,Rapid Response Team Update, the Monthly Coal Forecasting Process and PRB Train Loading Metrics.
Presentations made to the committee are available here:
Rapid Response Team ReportUnion Pacific Presentation
BNSF Presentation
PRB Joint Line Performance Metrics
2005 Joint Line Maintenance Plan
GE - Coal Supply Chain Management
The Western Logistics and Planning Committee was formed in the mid-1990's in the aftermath of major western Class 1 rail mergers involving the Burlington Northern and Santa Fe railroads, and the Union Pacific and Southern Pacific railroads. The integration of such large rail systems presented many operational, process, and technical challenges and concerns. The coal producer and coal consumer members of WCTA (now NCTA) came together and formed the Logistics and Planning Committee to seek solutions, in collaboration with the railroads, to the service difficulties encountered during this time. Due to the positive results of this cooperative effort, the Logistics and Planning Committee became a permanent standing subcommittee of the NCTA in 1998. Since that time, the Logistics and Planning Committee has gone on to tackle other planning and logistical issues as they have arisen with respect to western coal shipments. The following examples of the Western L&P's efforts contain links to more detailed information.
SRPB Joint Line Forecasting and Slotting Process - the NCTA Logistics and Planning Committee, working with both BNSF and UP railroads and consultants KPMG and Canac, facilitated an extensive third-party review and assessment of the validity of the forecasting and slotting process methodology used by the railroads for the SPRB Joint Line. The result of this outside assessment was an affirmation that the railroad forecasting and slotting process in place is reasonable and equitable.
Unique Identifier Process - as markets evolve, new challenges develop. As third party (brokered and traded) coal became a bigger part of the mix of SPRB shipments, issues with respect to the nomination and identification of third party trains arose. The NCTA Logistics and Planning Committee put together a process for expediting this which is in use by SPRB producers, together with other parties in the coal chain.
Train Parking Protocols - disruptions inevitably occur in the supply chain, and a significant disruption in the SPRB can quickly lead to serious train congestion which can translate into significant delayed and missed shipments. The NCTA Logistics and Planning Committee identified a need to have a planned approach to the temporary parking of trainsets due to either a producer issue or a railroad issue that would significantly impact the flow of shipments. The flowcharts that were created have become the protocols used by the BNSF and UP railroads for such situations.
Parking Protocols - Railroad Deviation from NCTA ForecastParking Protocols - Supply Side Deviation from NCTA Forecast
The NCTA Logistics and Planning Committee focuses on practical solutions to real-world problems, with the goal of improving the western coal supply chain. Various personnel representing coal producers, coal consumers, and the BNSF and UP railroads have been leaders in the Committee's work and in developing the processes and protocols described above. Of course, participation is voluntary.
To learn more about the NCTA Western Logistics and Planning Committee, please contact Bob Sarvela, Chairperson at bsarvela@midwestenergy.com or at 715-395-3505.


